Skip to content

Sources and Fact-Checking

Every claim on this site should lead back to a source you can check yourself. Here is what we count as good evidence, how we check claims and numbers, and how we show uncertainty.

What we count as evidence

We use the strongest evidence available for each question, roughly in this order:

  1. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses, which pool many studies on the same question.
  2. Randomised controlled trials, especially well-controlled feeding and training studies.
  3. Large cohort studies, for questions trials can’t answer, such as long-term health and daily steps.
  4. Reports and position statements from expert bodies, such as the FAO/WHO/UNU energy requirements report, the US National Academies, EFSA, the International Society of Sports Nutrition, the American College of Sports Medicine and the International Olympic Committee.
  5. Standard textbooks, for long-established physiology.

We avoid press releases, influencer content, company white papers and single small studies presented as proof. When a small study is the best evidence available, we say it is small.

How we check a claim

  • We read the study, not only the headline. For any number we quote, we check it in the paper itself, along with who was studied and for how long.
  • We match the claim to the people studied. A result from elite athletes isn’t presented as true for everyone, and a result from men isn’t presented as true for women without saying so.
  • We look for newer evidence. If later studies changed the picture, we describe the newer picture.
  • We link the source. Each guide lists its sources, with a DOI or official link where one exists, so you can check them too. The key studies are summarised in our research library.

How we check numbers

  • Worked examples are calculated with the same code that runs our calculators and the app, then checked by hand.
  • Units are converted with exact factors: 1 lb = 0.45359237 kg, 1 inch = 2.54 cm and 1 kcal = 4.184 kJ.
  • Results are rounded only for display, at the end of the calculation, so rounding errors don’t build up.
  • Rules of thumb, such as 7,700 kcal per kilo of body weight, are labelled as rough rules and explained.

How we show uncertainty

Calorie science is full of averages and individual differences. So we give ranges rather than single “correct” numbers where the evidence supports a range, explain how far an estimate can be off, and say when a recommendation rests on expert opinion or coaching practice rather than strong research. Words like “about”, “roughly” and “usually” are deliberate.

When sources disagree

Sometimes good sources point in different directions, for example on how large a muscle-building surplus should be, or which activity multipliers fit real life. We describe the disagreement, explain which approach our calculators use and why, and give you a way to test it for yourself, usually by tracking your weight for a few weeks.

Health claims

We never claim that our calculators or guides diagnose, treat or prevent a disease. When a topic involves a medical condition, such as PCOS or thyroid problems, we describe what research shows in general terms and recommend speaking to a doctor or registered dietitian. Read our health disclaimer for more.

Spotted a mistake?

Please tell us. Our corrections policy explains how, and our editorial policy describes how content is written and reviewed.